1. Corporate Governance
2. Public Governance
3. Global Governance and Research
4. Asset Recovery
5. Conferences and other public events
6. International relations and networking
7. Publications and media
8. Fundraising
1. Corporate Governance
In the field of corporate governance, the Institute focused chiefly on the acquisition and implementation of consulting mandates in the private sector, with particular attention to supporting corporations in developing comprehensive and functional internal anti-bribery compliance systems, as well as on the continuation of the Institute’s involvement in a number of key private sector industry standards against corruption and money laundering.
Anti-bribery compliance systems (consulting mandates)
- Conclusion (in November 2007) of a 1.5 year consulting mandate with an internationally operating oil company. Mandate consisted in supporting the company in the development and implementation of a comprehensive internal anti-bribery prevention and control system, including the drafting of policies and rules, the consultation with key company stakeholder groups (internal), and the provision of training.
- Signed contract with major, internationally operating corporation in the pharmaceutical sector for the on-going provision of ad hoc advice in the implementation of new or the revision of existing internal anti-bribery policies and procedures. Regular consultation has taken place throughout 2007 in the framework of this contract.
- New consulting mandate acquired with Panalpina, an internationally operating Swiss based freight forwarding corporation, for the support towards establishing and implementing comprehensive internal anti-bribery policies, rules and processes. Project ongoing (cf. Media section).
- Small consulting mandate in the F&B sector, to assist the company in developing an internal whistleblower protection system.
- Cooperation with World Conservation Union IUCN envisaged in 2008, for the implementation of the IUCN internal Code of Conduct.
Industry standards
Wolfsberg Group
The Wolfsberg Group jointly with the Basel Institute on Governance and Transparency International in Spring 2007 has publicly issued the Wolfsberg Statement against Corruption (www.wolfsberg-principles.com/statement_against_corruption.html) which had previously been approved for submission to the member bank’s Boards at the Winter meeting of the Wolfsberg Group on 12 and 13 December 2006 in Berlin. Even after this Statement has been completed, and including at the insistence of the Basel Institute on Governance’s representatives in the Wolfsberg Group, the issue of corruption remains on the Group’s ongoing work programme.
In December a joint Wolfsberg Group FATF Typologies meeting took place in London which included a corruption work stream that was jointly chaired by Philippe de Koster from the Belgian FIU and Hans-Peter Bauer for the Basel Institute. Participants included regulators, international organisations, law enforcement and police officers as well as anti-money laundering specialists from the banking sector. Whilst it was generally recognised that it is difficult to define specific banking transactions as indicators for corruption related activities, the group managed to define a number of areas that would be worth while to pursue further. Special attention should be given to the identification, the role and the monitoring of intermediaries. As the OECD is already doing work in this area, Philippe de Koster suggested inviting Mark Pieth to the next meeting.
As a further related activity, at the suggestion of the Basel Institute on Governance, the Group has invited a representative of the UN Office on Drugs and Crime, the custodian of the recently enacted UN Convention against Corruption (UNCAC), to present the UNCAC and the on-going process in various areas of interest to the Group during the Winter meeting in Zurich. As a consequence, the Wolfsberg Group has been invited to participate and speak at the forthcoming 2nd UNCAC Conference of States Parties, to be held in late January in Bali, Indonesia.
To improve the implementation of FATF Special Recommendation VII for the fight against the Financing of Terrorism, the Group has worked closely with international regulators and SWIFT to develop an enhanced message type for cover payments that will improve the transparency in the international flow of money.
Hans-Peter Bauer has represented the Basel Institute on Governance in the Wolfsberg Group at the Group’s Spring, Autumn and Winter meetings (the latter jointly with Gretta Fenner), and has also attended, together with Mark Pieth and Gretta Fenner, the Wolfsberg Forum in May/June 2007 in Wolfsberg, Switzerland.
World Economic Forum Partnering Against Corruption Initiative
The Institute continues to support and actively promote and facilitate the work of the World Economic Forum Partnering Against Corruption Initiative (PACI), both through Mark Pieth’s membership in the Board of the Initiative and Gretta Fenner’s membership in the Initiative’s Task Force. The Institute was represented at the Annual Meeting of the World Economic Forum in Davos in January 2007, during which the world’s four big accounting firms could be won to sign up to and actively participate in the Initiative.
The Initiative’s Task Force has undergone an important development from a primarily process and self-management oriented institution to an extremely lively forum for experience sharing and dialogue on implementation of anti-bribery principles in practice. This has been acknowledged by member firms as being the real value added of PACI. Work on further developing the three step implementation mechanism is also ongoing, and efforts are being made to ensure that signatory companies fulfil their commitment by means of actual implementation measures within their firms on the one hand, and participation in PACI activities and reporting procedures on the other hand.
Finally, efforts are being made to further strengthen cooperation with the other key private sector anti-corruption initiatives, ie the ICC Standards on Extortion and Bribery, the TI Business Principles and the UN Global Compact, and with other key public anti-corruption institutions such as the OECD Working Group on Bribery and the UN Office on Drugs and Crime as the custodians of the OECD Anti-Bribery Convention and the UN Convention against Corruption, respectively.
Work on new industry standards
- A new country specific anti-bribery initiative has been initiated in the course of 2007 and is likely to be launched publicly in 2008, with a particular focus on a country that is known to be particularly prone to corruption on the one hand and on the other hand is highly relevant in relation to international trade and foreign investment.
- New and promising attempt towards the re-establishment of an industry initiative in the powers sector made in second half of 2007
- Initial discussion of industry standard in logistics/freight forwarding industry
- Initial discussion of industry standard / governance principles for the NGO sector in cooperation with a major international NGO coalition
2. Public Governance
- UN Convention against Corruption compliance review/gap analysis of Bangladesh, in cooperation with the BRAC University Centre for Governance Studies and funded by GTZ (on-going into 2008).
- UN Convention against Corruption compliance review/gap analysis of Kenya, in cooperation with the Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission (KACC) and funded by GTZ (on-going into 2008).
- Organisation of Belgrade 2007 Transparency Days, at request of and funded by the Embassy of Switzerland in Serbia.
- Development of anti-corruption training concept for GtZ Mauretania.
- Drafting of country study Indonesia on “national anti-corruption strategies” (effectiveness, hindering and triggering forces, scope etc.) mandated by U4 and funded by the GTZ as part of a comparative study on the implementation of Article 5 of UNCAC.
- Participation in ICAR fact-finding missions to Indonesia and Tanzania, to support ICAR team and to explore additional (non-asset recovery) areas of collaboration with respective local counterparts
- Exploratory mission to Business Keepers Monitoring System (BKMS) offices in Berlin to evaluate usefulness of BKSM for Indonesian whistleblower system (mandated by GTZ), project proposal under evaluation in Indonesia.
- Development of training session for public officials from Lithuania, in cooperation with the Lithuanian Centre of Economic Training), to take place in Vilnius in February 2008.
- Organisation, at request of Govt. of Indonesia, of 2-day regional seminar on Asset Recovery and MLA in Asia and the Pacific (Bali, Indonesia, 5-7 September 2007), with funding from GtZ and UNODC.
- Submitted various offers for anti-corruption reform programmes (e.g. Burkina Faso/UNDP, Bangladesh/UNDP, Bhutan/Helvetas, Bhutan/UNDP, Tanzania/Finland, Africa/AFDB-OECD)
- Provided comments on UNCAC technical guidance document
3. Global Governance and Research
- 1-day expert workshop, organised by Basel Institute on Governance and Swiss Tropical Institute (December 2007) with contributions by researchers from South Africa and the Kyrgyz Republic, to review and finalise the new submission of a joint 3-year research project on “Governance of Essential Health Care Systems”.
- Research paper on corruption and human rights in the context of National Integrity Systems, mandated and funded by the International Council on Human Rights Policy (ICHRP); a revised version of this paper is to be published in an edited volume by the Kennedy School of Government.
- First draft of working paper on Trade, Corruption and Human Rights jointly with and funded by the World Trade Institute. Final draft to be completed in first half 2008.
- Submission for funding to various donors of applied research project on „Governance and Conflict – Lessons learnt from multistakeholder initiatives“,developed jointly with Swisspeace (funding decisions awaited)
- The role of local governance in promoting/hindering full enjoyment of the rights by affected populations, research proposal submitted for funding to various donors jointly with Human Solutions Consulting (funding decisions awaited).
4. Asset Recovery
Launched in mid-2006 with substantial seed funding from the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC) and the Principality of Liechtenstein, the Institute’s International Centre for Asset Recovery (ICAR) experienced an intense period of start up activities and operations in 2007. The Centre focused on launching its pilot asset recovery training programs, building national and international partnership arrangements to heighten its profile and expand its network of partners and experts, as well as on mobilizing both human and financial resources to allow it to implement its mandate through 2008 and onward. Key activities in 2007 included the following:
Trainings
The ICAR developed and implemented four asset recovery training programs in four countries:
- Indonesia: Intermediate asset tracing, recovery and repatriation training for the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) and the Attorney General’s Office, Jakarta,September 2007
- Bangladesh: Mutual Legal Assistance and Asset Recovery Capacity Building (Operationalising UNCAC Chapter V) for the Bangladesh Asset Recovery Task Force (Part I, a training workshop series), Dhaka, November 2007
- Brazil: Investigative Techniques, Case Management and Data Analysis to Combat Money Laundering and the Financing of Terrorism, for judges and prosecutors from the various states of Brazil, co-sponsored together with the Brazilian Ministry of Justice and the United Nations Interregional Crime and Justice Research Institute, (Brasilia, November 2007)
- Tanzania: Mutual Legal Assistance and Asset Recovery Capacity Building (Operationalising UNCAC Chapter V) for the Prevention of Corruption Bureau, Dar Es Salam, December 2007
The development and implementation of these training programs involved assessment missions and country-specific research to integrate domestic laws and legal procedures into the training programme. Furthermore, where requested and to ensure that the trainings were of particularly high relevance to on-going cases, ICAR involved a number of external experts from various key financial centres (Singapore, Malaysia, United Kingdom, Nigeria, and Switzerland) in the trainings. On average, 20 participants attended each training event.
ICAR is further developing follow-up assistance and mentoring components for the participants and partner institutions of these trainings. These may include legal drafting assistance, case coaching or follow-up trainings. Furthermore, a number of requests for trainings from countries in Latin America and Africa were received and will be evaluated in the first quarter of 2008.
Finally, the ICAR at the invitation of UNODC contributed to the training workshop on “Non-conviction based forfeiture systems and the management and control of assets pre- and post confiscation”, organized by UNODC in cooperation with the Nigerian Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (Nigeria, November 2007)
Case assistance
ICAR has received a number of requests for strategic case advice both in the context of training activities as well as independently from other projects. The ICAR is actively engaged in accompanying the relevant authorities in a selected number of cases, after having carefully analyzed the respective requests. The case assistance activities are likely to be intensified in the course of 2008, as more evidence and case activity in all these cases is to be expected. The ICAR further advises the Swiss NGO coalition on the return of Duvalier funds to Haiti in technical matters.
Asset Recovery Knowledge Center
Important resources were invested during 2007 in the development of ICAR’s online Knowledge Centre for Asset Recovery which, by the end of 2007, consisted of several prototype functions and contained a satisfactory amount of information, in particular a number of “country profiles” ready for its official launch at the Second Conference of States Parties (COSP) to the UNCAC (Bali, January 2008).
Once launched at the COSP, the Knowledge Center becomes accessible to the public free of charge and through a self-serve web portal (www.assetrecovery.org). The aim of this hub is to provide a research and case relevant assistance facility on asset recovery, by housing relevant international treaties, bilateral agreements and domestic laws relevant to MLA and asset recovery and related fields such as anti-money laundering. It also provides case analysis and secondary literature, as well as an extensive database of contacts of relevant authorities in most countries around the world.
Other asset recovery projects
- Assisted the Kenyan Anti-Corruption Commission (KACC) to assess and determine asset recovery capacity gaps in the framework of the Basel Institute on Governance’s mandate to assist the KACC in analyzing Kenya’s compliance with the UN Convention against Corruption under its five chapters. First assessment mission in November 2007. Project to be continued in 2008.
- Commenced work with Transparency International-UK to compile a report on the UK’s performance on prosecuting overseas corruption and asset recovery (November 2007). Project to be continued in 2008.
5. Conferences and Public events
- Combating Fraud and Corruption in the European Union (1-2 February 2007, Trier, Germany). Co-organised with the European Academy of Law, and funded by the European Anti-Fraud Office OLAF.
- The Role of Nonstate Actors in Standard Setting (8-9 February 2007, Basel, Switzerland). International academic research conference with approximately 120 participants from Switzerland, Europe, Northern America, Africa and Asia.
- Two Asset Recovery Donors meetings (March and May 2007, Basel, Switzerland).
- Expert Workshop on “Implementing the Asset Recovery Provisions of the UN Convention against Corruption” (15-16 May 2007, Basel, Switzerland). Organised jointly with the UN Office on Drugs and Crime.
- Brownbag Lunch with Dr. Jillian Clare Cohen, Assistant Professor at the Leslie Dan Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Toronto (21 May 2007, Basel), on “Good Governance in the Pharmaceutical System: Why it is a Matter of Life and Death?”.
- Brownbag Lunch with Guy Dehn, Director of Public Concerns at Work (11 September 2007, Basel), on “Whistleblower protection: the experience of the United Kingdom”.
- Awareness raising and policy consultation meeting on whistleblowing, organised for the Swiss Federal Administration, to support current legal drafting process on the subject. Guest expert: Guy Dehn, Public Concerns at Work (11 September 2007, Bern, Switzerland).
- Conference on Accounting, Auditing and Compliance in Corporate Groups (8 November 2007, Zurich, Switzerland). Organised by the Europa Institute of the Zurich University and Prof Lukas Handschin from the University of Basel/Basel Institute on Governance, in cooperation with the Basel Institute on Governance.
- Protection of EU and Swiss Financial Interests – Challenges for law enforcement and the financial industry (10-11 December 2007, Basel, Switzerland). Co-organised with the European Academy of Law, and funded by the European Anti-Fraud Office OLAF.
6. International relations and networking
Partnerships
- In June 2007, the Basel Institute on Governance signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the UN Office for Drugs and Crime (UNODC) which outlines areas of cooperation, roles and responsibilities in the implementation of the UN Convention against Corruption (UNCAC); as a consequence, the Basel Institute on Governance has become an associate member of the UN Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice Programme Network (PNI) and attended its first PNI meeting in Turin, Italy, in December 2007.
- The Basel Institute is also collaborating actively with other international organisations involved in fostering governance, combating corruption and promoting the recovery of stolen assets, such as the World Bank, UNICRI, the African Development Bank, the OECD, the Asian Development Bank, Interpol, etc.. Details for these collaborations are contained in this report’s individual project descriptions.
Participation in conferences, public speeches etc.
- Presentation on corporate anti-bribery compliance and whistleblowing in a public workshop organised by Deloitte&Touche (April 2007)
- Two presentations to Novo Norsk Middle East in April and May 2007 in Athens, Greece, on corruption and development, and on whistleblowing protection, respectively.
- ICAR, in cooperation with the Swiss Attorney General’s Office, gave a general presentation on “The role of Switzerland in asset recovery” for an Indonesian delegation consisting of middle-ranking officials from various Indonesian public offices involved in the prosecution of corruption and asset recovery, including the Ministry of Justice, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Police Department. Swiss public official from (Basel, June 2007)
- Participated in public panel discussion on corruption prevention in SMEs, organised by Sustainability Forum Zurich (June 2007)
- Participated in and presented ICAR at the Corruption Hunter Network of the Norwegian Agency for Development (NORAD) in Norway (June 2007)
- Attended the First and Second Conference of the International Association of Anti-Corruption Authorities (IAACA) in China (June 2007) and in Bali (October 2007).
- Participated in and spoke at the ICHRP Review meeting on Corruption and Human Rights (July 2007, Geneva, Switzerland)
- Attended the meetings of the three Open-Ended UNCAC Working Groups on Monitoring, Implementation and Asset Recovery (August and October 2007, respectively).
- Participated as expert in the GRECO evaluation of Switzerland, at the invitation of seco (18 September 2008).
- Participated in and spoke at the WHO Expert Group meeting on Good Governance in Medicines (September 2007, Geneva, Switzerland)
- Participated in and presented ICAR at the UNDP Regional Conference on Corruption and Money Laundering, “Strengthening the Rule of Law in Arab States – Project on Modernization of Public Prosecution Officios (October 2007, Egypt)
- ICAR hosted the visit of, and gave a general presentation about ICAR, to the Indonesian Asset Recovery Task Force consisting of select inter-departmental delegates from the Attorney General’s Office, the Department of Foreign Affairs and the Department of Law and Human Rights (Basel, November 2007)
- Presentation on “The same benchmarks apply to all: Accountability, oversight and regulation in the not-for-profit sector”, at the occasion of the sixth Symposium of the Swiss Health Cooperation (Schweizerische Gesundheitszusammenarbeit) on 6 November 2007, in Berne, Switzerland.
- Participated in public panel discussion organised by Ernst&Young on the recovery of stolen assets (26 September 2007, London, UK)
- Participated in and presented the Institute at the 12th Plenary Session of the International Scientific and Professional Council of the United Nations Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice Programme (ISPAC) and the ISPAC Annual Conference 2007 on “The evolving challenge of identity-related crime: Addressing fraud and the criminal misuse and falsification of identity” (29-30 November and 30 November-2 December 2007, respectively, Courmayeur, Italy).
7. Publications and media
Publications
- Verhaltensregeln für die Verwaltung von Vorsorgeeinrichtungen, by Mark Pieth, -Peter Bauer, Lukas Handschin, HansAndreas Müller, and Gretta Fenner, Basel Institute on Governance Working Paper 03, February 2007.
- The international dimensions of judicial accountability. By Zora Ledergerber, Gretta Fenner, Mark Pieth, in: Global Corruption Report 2007 (Corruption in Judicial Systems), Cambridge University Press/Transparency International, 2007 (www.transparency.org).
- Einfach schweigen? By Zora Ledergerber, in: Wir Kaufleute – Monatszeitschrift des Kaufmännischen Verbands Zürich (01/07).
- U4 Brief on Asset Recovery. By Guillermo Jorge, Mark Pieth and Jack D. Smith, at request of U4 Anti-Corruption Resource Centre (www.u4.no).
- Preparation of edited volume on “Recovering Stolen Assets” (Pieth, Basel Institute on Governance, ed.), will be published by Peter Lang AG in January 2008.
- Preparation of edited volume on the “Role of Non-State Actors in Standard Setting” (Fenner, Förster, Koechlin u Peters, eds.), submitted to Cambridge University Press for evaluation.
- Preparation of co-publication with Asian Development Bank and OECD on mutual legal assistance and asset recovery (conference proceedings from Bali regional Asia-Pacific conference), will be published by ADB in first half 2008.
Media reports, newspaper articles etc. about the Institute and its activities:
- Regeln macht der Staat, oder? Wie sich Banken oder die Holzindustrie selbst regulieren | Basler Zeitung | Saturday, 10 February 2007 | page 33.
- "Korruption wurde gefördert" - Zertifizierung erhöht "ethisches Kapital" von Firmen | Basler Zeitung | Saturday, 10 February 2007 | page 33.
- Korruption kostet Leben | Basler Zeitung | Tuesday, 22 May 2007 | page 31.
- Potentatengelder als Reputationsrisiko für den Finanzplatz Schweiz - Drohendes Debakel im Fall Duvalier | by Mark Pieth | NZZ | Tuesday, 06 June 2007 | page 27.
- Schweiz tut sich schwer mit Diktatoren-Geldern | SR DRS Echo der Zeit | Monday 26 June 2007 | Radio | Summary: Die Gefahr ist gross, dass die Millionenvermögen der Diktatoren Duvalier und Mobutu aus Haiti und Kongo in der Schweiz nicht weggeschafft werden. Denn ihre Länder haben keine Rechtshilfegesuche gestellt. Damit könnten die Diktatoren und ihre Familien das unrechtmässig erworbene Geld behalten. Wie lässt sich das verhindern? Markus Mugglin im Gespräch mit dem Basler Strafrechtsprofessor Mark Pieth.
- Whistleblowers inch towards more protection (Switzerland) | Swissinfo | 28 June 2007.
- Global OK needed for missing assets | Jakarta Post | 6 September 2007.
- Participation at Transparency International press conference at the occasion of the launch of the 2007 Corruption Perception Index (26 September 2007, London, UK)
- Kontakte, Zusammenarbeit Konferenz | Betrügerisches Milliardenkarussell | Zollbetrug in der Schweiz | Basler Zeitung | 10 December 2007.
- Kampf den transnationalen Steuerdelikten - Was vom Betrugsbekämpfungsvertrag Schweiz-EU zu erwarten ist | NZZ | 12 December 2007.
- Schweiz will Umsetzung der bilateralen Verträge | Basler Zeitung | 12 December 2007.
8. Fundraising
Governance
Little progress was made in terms of expanding the basis for seed funding for the Governance activities of the Institute. However, major project contributions for conferences were received from OLAF, the GtZ and the US State Department/UNODC. The Institute further succeeded in raising smaller project related sponsoring contributions from a variety of institutions, including (in alphabetical order), Bank Sarasin & Cie. AG; BIZ Stiftung; British Council Switzerland; Gregory Bruch and Akita Adkins, Foley & Lardner, USA; Lucinda Low, Steptoe & Johnson LLP, USA; NCCR Trade Regulation; Schweizerische Akademie der Geistes- und Sozialwissenschaften (SAGW); Swiss Directorate of Public International Law; Swiss National Foundation; and UBS AG.
Asset Recovery
In May 2007, the ICAR acquired a third donor, the UK Department for International Development (DFID), to fund the secondment of an anti-corruption specialist (Alan Bacarese) from the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) to the ICAR for three years. This acquisition met the condition of the SDC, as stated in its Memorandum of Understanding with the ICAR, that ICAR obtain a third donor by the end of June 2007 before SDC could confirm its funding support through 2010. The core donors of ICAR now include the SDC, the Principality of Liechtenstein, and the United Kingdom.
Furthermore, the ICAR was able to attract project funding from the GTZ and the African Development Bank, and to establish a funding partnership with the World Bank, to fund specific training programmes in Indonesia, Tanzania and Bangladesh in 2007.
